For many homeowners in Toronto and the GTA, there comes a point when the existing space simply doesn’t feel like enough anymore. Maybe your family is growing, maybe you’re working from home more often, or maybe your lifestyle has changed and you want more comfort and functionality. This raises a major question:
Should you buy a new home, or expand the one you already have with a home addition?
There’s no one-size-fits-all answer. Both paths come with unique financial, personal, and long-term considerations. Below, we break down the pros and cons of each to help you make a confident decision.
1. Understanding Your Current Home and Property
Before making any decisions, consider:
-
Do you like your neighbourhood?
-
Are schools, transit, shops, and daily routines already convenient?
-
Do you have emotional attachment to your home?
-
Is your lot large enough to support an addition (rear, side, or second floor)?
If you love where you live, a home addition might allow you to stay rooted while gaining the space you need. If the location is no longer ideal, buying a new home could be more practical.
2. Cost Comparison: Buying vs. Building
Home Addition Costs
Home additions in Toronto vary widely, but generally:
| Rear or Side Addition |
$250–$350+ per sq. ft. |
| Second Floor Addition |
$300–$450+ per sq. ft. |
| Full Gut + Addition |
$350–$550+ per sq. ft. |
In many cases, an addition will be more cost-effective than purchasing a new home when factoring in moving expenses, land transfer tax, and closing costs.
Buying a New Home Costs
When buying, the price goes beyond the sticker number:
-
Toronto Land Transfer Tax
-
Ontario Land Transfer Tax
-
Realtor fees
-
Legal fees
-
Moving costs
-
Renovation after purchase (most homes still need updates)
A move that starts as $1.5M might realistically cost $1.6M+ after all fees.
So financially, adding space to your existing home is often more predictable than moving.
3. Timeline and Convenience
Home Addition
-
Requires architectural drawings, permits, and construction.
-
May mean living through renovations, or temporary relocation.
However, the result is custom-built space tailored to your lifestyle.
Buying a New Home
-
The timeline is shorter, but involves house hunting, bidding wars, and competitive markets.
-
The house may still require renovation afterwards to fit your needs.
4. Impact on Property Value
Both buying and renovating can increase value, but a well-planned home addition often has a strong return on investment, especially when adding:
-
Additional bedrooms
-
A larger kitchen
-
A primary suite
-
Basement finishing
-
Second floor expansions
Homes with more usable square footage typically sell faster and for more.
5. Lifestyle Factors
Ask yourself:
-
Does moving feel exciting or stressful?
-
Do you want a fresh start or to enhance what you already have?
-
Is your family okay with living through construction noise?
A home addition is perfect for families who want to stay where they are and personalize their space.
Buying may be better if you’re seeking major lifestyle or location changes, such as a different school district, more outdoor land, or a newer style of home.
6. When a Home Addition Makes the Most Sense
Choose a home addition if:
- You love your current location
- Your lot and zoning allow expansion
- You want to increase property value
- You prefer customizing your living space
7. When Buying a New Home Is the Better Choice
Buying new may be better if:
- You want a different neighbourhood or commute
- Your current home has structural limitations
- Your lot cannot support expansion
- Renovation disruption doesn’t suit your lifestyle
If you love your neighbourhood, want to stay close to your routine, and prefer customizing your home to fit your life, a home addition is usually the smarter long-term investment.
However, if your needs go beyond just space—such as location change, lot size, outdoor lifestyle, or different community vibes—then purchasing a new home may offer the fresh start you’re looking for.
